2027 open enrollment

CareSource leaving the Marketplace in 2027: Indiana, Ohio and West Virginia

Quick answer

CareSource says it will no longer offer Marketplace plans in Indiana, Ohio, and West Virginia as of January 1, 2027. Current coverage stays active through December 31, 2026. Pick a new plan by December 15, 2026 for a January 1 start. CareSource's Ohio Medicaid and MyCare Ohio plans are not affected.

Call a licensed agentMon–Sat 8 AM–9 PM ET · No fee for our help

Ascend Health Consultants is a licensed insurance agency, and our agents licensed in all 50 states compare plans from several companies for you. We never charge you a fee for our help.

CareSource is ending Marketplace plans in Indiana, Ohio, and West Virginia

CareSource's own provider notices, dated May 15, 2026 (Indiana) and May 20, 2026 (Ohio and West Virginia), say that as of January 1, 2027, CareSource will no longer offer plans through the Health Insurance Marketplace in those states. The notices say members' Marketplace and off-exchange Qualified Health Plan coverage stays active through December 31, 2026, and that members will move to other coverage during open enrollment.

The Ohio notice adds that the change does not affect CareSource's Ohio Medicaid or MyCare Ohio plans. This page is only about the individual Marketplace and off-exchange plans.

How many people does it affect? Health and Tech Now estimates about 113,000 CareSource Marketplace customers across the three states, using CMS's 2025 county enrollment counts. That is an outside estimate, not a CareSource figure.

What to do before December 15

  1. Read both letters. HealthCare.gov says you should get one from your current insurer and one from the Marketplace by November 1. The Marketplace letter names the plan you will be re-enrolled in if you take no action.
  2. Update your 2027 income estimate on HealthCare.gov so your premium tax credit is right. See ACA subsidies in 2027.
  3. Check your doctors and prescriptions against each plan you are considering. Our guide: how to check if a doctor is in network.
  4. Enroll by December 15, 2026 for coverage that starts January 1, 2027. Open enrollment runs through January 15, 2027, with a typical February 1 start for later picks.

If you take no action, HealthCare.gov says it will re-enroll you in a plan with a different insurance company. Learn how that works in does HealthCare.gov automatically renew?

Ohio: who is selling 2027 Marketplace plans

The Ohio Department of Insurance says it approved 9 companies to sell on Ohio's 2027 exchange, compared with 11 for 2026. Its list: AmeriHealth Caritas Ohio, Antidote Health Plan of Ohio, Buckeye Community Health Plan, Community Insurance Company, Medical Mutual of Ohio, two Oscar companies, Summa Insurance Company, and UnitedHealthcare of Ohio. The department says only five counties have two insurers, and every other county has three or more. Molina is also not on Ohio's 2027 list; see Molina leaving the Marketplace in 2027. More on the state: health insurance in Ohio.

Indiana and West Virginia

In Indiana, CareSource and Cigna are both leaving the Marketplace for 2027, according to Coverage Decider's review of insurer and Indiana Department of Insurance notices. AmeriHealth Caritas says it is debuting Marketplace plans in Indiana for 2027, in seven counties covering central Indiana. See health insurance in Indiana. In West Virginia, Policymage lists CareSource leaving all 55 counties it served. See health insurance in West Virginia.

Marketplace plan or private plan?

If you qualify for a premium tax credit, a new Marketplace plan keeps that help. If you earn too much for a credit, or you want a national PPO network, licensed private plans sold outside the Marketplace are worth a look; many can be applied for year-round. Our agents licensed in all 50 states can compare both at no fee. Call (813) 724-3314 or request a quote.

Replace your CareSource plan with help from a licensed agent. Call (813) 724-3314 (Monday–Saturday 8 AM–9 PM ET, Sunday closed) or get your free quote. Prefer a set time? Book a call. We never charge you a fee for our help.

Call (813) 724-3314

Frequently asked questions

Is CareSource leaving the Marketplace in 2027?

Yes, in Indiana, Ohio, and West Virginia. CareSource's notices say that as of January 1, 2027, it will no longer offer Marketplace plans in those states, and that current coverage remains active through December 31, 2026.

Is CareSource leaving Ohio in 2027?

For Marketplace and off-exchange individual plans, yes. CareSource's Ohio notice says the change does not affect its Ohio Medicaid or MyCare Ohio plans.

What happens if I don't pick a new plan?

HealthCare.gov says that if your insurance company is not offering plans next year and you take no action by December 15, it will re-enroll you in a plan with a different insurance company. Review that plan, or choose your own by December 15 for a January 1 start.

Which insurers are selling in Ohio's Marketplace for 2027?

The Ohio Department of Insurance lists 9 companies approved for 2027, including AmeriHealth Caritas Ohio, Antidote Health Plan of Ohio, Buckeye Community Health Plan, Community Insurance Company, Medical Mutual of Ohio, two Oscar companies, Summa Insurance Company, and UnitedHealthcare of Ohio. Availability varies by county.

Do I need a Special Enrollment Period to switch?

Not during open enrollment, which runs through January 15, 2027. After that, losing a plan because the insurer left can count as a loss of coverage; see our Special Enrollment Period guide.

Can I get a private plan instead?

Many licensed private plans can be applied for year-round. Premium tax credits apply only to Marketplace plans. Call (813) 724-3314 or request a quote to compare.

Related guides

Reviewed by licensed agents working with Ascend Health Consultants. We're an independent health insurance agency based in the Tampa Bay area. Ascend Health Consultants LLC works with licensed agents who are licensed in all 50 states, helping individuals, families and the self-employed find private health coverage. How we write and review content

Plan availability and eligibility are determined by the carrier. Carrier, plan and network names are trademarks of their respective owners and are used only to identify those products. This page is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Confirm current figures and program rules with the official sources linked above and with a licensed agent.