Why people choose a private plan over COBRA
- Often a lower monthly premium than full-price COBRA.
- Keep a PPO network with Cigna PPO plans.
- Apply any time — not just in the 60-day election window.
- Short-term options that can start as soon as the next day.
COBRA alternative health insurance options
| Option | Cost | Keeps your doctors? | Deadline |
|---|---|---|---|
| COBRA | Full premium + up to 2% admin fee | Yes — same plan | Generally 60 days to elect |
| Spouse's employer plan | Varies | Depends | Usually 30 days (check plan) |
| Private PPO plan | Often less than COBRA | Depends on network | Year-round |
| Short-term plan | Usually lowest premium | Depends | Year-round where sold |
Step-by-step: deciding in your first two weeks
- Find your coverage end date and your COBRA election notice.
- Get a private plan quote — Ameristead on the Cigna PPO network, UnitedHealthOne and short-term options.
- Compare the monthly cost of each private plan with your COBRA premium.
- Remember COBRA's safety net: you generally have 60 days to elect COBRA, and it's retroactive if you elect and pay — but don't let deadlines pass without a plan.
COBRA vs private health insurance
COBRA vs private health insurance often favors a private plan: you can apply any time, keep a PPO network and pay far less than full COBRA premiums.
Retiring early rather than changing jobs? See health insurance for early retirees.
Deciding on COBRA? Talk it through with a licensed agent. We'll put COBRA next to private plans for your doctors, in one call.
Call (813) 724-3314Book a call for when we're open
Monday–Saturday 8 AM–9 PM ET, Sunday closed · Get your free quote · Prefer a set time? Book a call. We never charge you a fee for our help.
What to do this week if you got a COBRA notice
- Read your COBRA election notice and note the election deadline and the monthly cost it lists.
- List your doctors, hospitals and prescriptions so you can check them in each plan's network.
- Compare COBRA with private plans, a spouse's plan and the Marketplace. HealthCare.gov says losing job-based coverage can open a Special Enrollment Period if it happened in the past 60 days or is expected in the next 60 days.
- Pick a start date with no gap between your old coverage and the new plan.
- Call a licensed agent at (813) 724-3314 (Mon–Sat 8 AM–9 PM ET) to compare your options side by side.
Frequently asked questions
Is there anything cheaper than COBRA?
Often, yes. Private PPO plans like Ameristead, short-term plans and a spouse's plan are frequently cheaper than full COBRA premiums.
Can I switch from COBRA to a private plan?
Yes. Private plans can be bought year-round, so you can compare them any time, including while you're on COBRA.
How long does COBRA last?
Usually up to 18 months after a job loss; some events allow up to 36 months.
Planning a short break before your next role? Here is how to choose health insurance between jobs.
Related guides
Health insurance guides by state
Deadlines, exchanges, average premiums and short-term plan rules differ by state. Popular state guides:
Sources (checked November 11, 2026)
- U.S. Department of Labor — COBRA continuation coverage
- HealthCare.gov — Special Enrollment Periods
Plan availability and eligibility are determined by the carrier.