Agent vs. broker
| Who | What they can do | How they're paid |
|---|---|---|
| Independent agent / broker | Compare and sell plans from several insurers | Commission from the insurer |
| Captive agent | Sells one insurer's plans only | Commission or salary from that insurer |
Do health insurance brokers cost money?
Usually not. Insurers pay brokers a commission that's built into premiums whether you use a broker or not. If anyone asks you for a separate fee, ask what it's for and get it in writing.
What an independent health insurance agent actually does
- Compares private plans from several carriers on total yearly cost.
- Shows private, short-term and PPO options side by side where they fit, and explains how the options compare.
- Checks your doctors and prescriptions against each plan's network and formulary.
- Helps with enrollment, life-event changes, renewals and claims questions after you buy.
How to check a broker before you buy
- Verify the license. Look up the agent or agency on NIPR or your state department of insurance.
- Ask which insurers they're appointed with. More carriers means a fairer comparison.
- Get plan names in writing, including the network and deductible, before you pay.
- Never share your account logins. A legitimate agent doesn't need them, and you should approve any changes to your application.
Looking for a health insurance agent near you?
We're an independent agency based in Tampa, working with licensed agents who are licensed in all 50 states (not DC). We never charge you a fee for our help. We meet clients in person around Tampa Bay and help everyone else by phone or video, so "near me" works wherever you live.
What is a health insurance broker, and how to find one near me
A health insurance broker is a licensed agent who compares plans from several insurers. If you're looking for a health insurance broker near me, check their state license on NIPR. Shopping outside the Marketplace? See how to find a private health insurance broker.
Based in Florida? Meet our Tampa health insurance agents. Comparing plan types? See PPO vs HMO vs EPO.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an insurance agent and a broker?
In everyday use the terms overlap. Both are state-licensed. "Broker" and "independent agent" usually mean someone who represents several insurers; a captive agent represents one.
Will using a broker raise my premium?
No. Commissions are generally built into the filed rate, and we never charge you a fee for our help.
Related guides
Health insurance guides by state
Deadlines, exchanges, average premiums and short-term plan rules differ by state. Popular state guides:
Sources (checked November 4, 2026)
- NIPR — Look up a producer license
- NAIC — State insurance department directory
Plan availability and eligibility are determined by the carrier.